Comments on SHANDE: 3 idiots: movie and the controversy

nice one...though i somewhat disagree with you...w...

2010-01-26T13:26:36.779+05:30

nice one...though i somewhat disagree with you...whatever be the case, our film makers are used to 'lifting' stories without proper credits, not to mention music. The starting seed of thought was from the book means that the book should get its due. since the movie is indeed somewhat different and so well made, the producers could have played their cards better by saying "Movie inspired by..." and let people figure it out. It in no way would have lessened the number of fans or their box office collection.

the complete agreement copy is here: http://www.vi...

2010-01-03T08:41:06.642+05:30

the complete agreement copy is here: http://www.vinodchopra.com
/agreement.pdf,

It says title will read "based on the novel FIVE POINT SOMEONE by Chetan Bhagat"- doesn't say in what font size and when and where...

one can also refer to CB's blog for his version of the story.

Nice gist of the soiled fight which is rather gett...

2010-01-03T01:04:48.445+05:30

Nice gist of the soiled fight which is rather getting filthy.

Bottom line is that it is helping the cause of the film. It's sales.

No INDIAN will stop watching this movie even though if they prove its a a copy without credits.

We don't believe in originality anyways. All we want is entertainment be it thru movie or their cat fight.

My take it is enjoy the fight and get along with your life ...